Our Team

Meet The Agency Founder & Partner

Rita McMullen

CPCU/AAI President & Sales

Rita started working at what is now PDM Insurance Agency back in 1986. She has since made PDM into what it is today! Rita has an Associates Degree in Marketing from Penn State University. In her spare time, she enjoys traveling and camping with her family & friends. Rita & her husband have one daughter, Jess, and live on their farm with their beloved dog, two miniature donkeys, and Rita’s retired Show Horse.

Jess McMullen

CPIA/CLCS Agency Partner

CROP, FARM, BUSINESS, & MORTALITY AGENT

Jess started working at PDM Insurance in 2013. She is a graduate from Texas A&M University with a bachelors  degree in animal science. In her spare time, she enjoys riding & showing horses, swimming, as well as traveling with her two dogs & show horse.

CHAMBERSBURG Office

Jayme Barthalow

Personal Lines Agent

Jayme started at PDM in 2022. Originally from Blair County in Central PA. Jayme’s hobbies include working out and wellness, attending new breweries, traveling and spending time with friends and family.

Deena Newman

CPIA/AFIS Farm & Life Agent

Deena started with PDM in 1998. Deena enjoys the outdoors, traveling and spending time with family & friends.

Rachelle Creadon

Agency Support Specialist

Rachelle joined the PDM Team in 2023 bringing an extensive amount of customer service experience to the agency. A native of Greencastle, she likes to spend time with her family and pets.

Path Valley Office

Angie Lininger

CPIA, Controller & Accounting/IT

Angie started at PDM in 1998. She has an Associate of Science in Accounting. She spends time with her family including a daughter, four grandkids and dog, Edge. Hobbies are taking vacations, walks, sitting around a campfire, kayaking and shooting pool.

Jen Coons

AFIS Crop & Mortality Agent

Jen started at PDM in 2005. Jen is a graduate of Shippensburg University with a bachelors in Human Resources. Jen’s favorite hobbies are shopping, spending time with her niece & nephew and cooking.

Adams county Office

Chaz Augustine-Timmons

CPIA Personal Lines & Life Agent, Marketing Director, TACC Board Member

Chaz started at PDM Insurance in 2017. Originally from Mercersburg, Chaz is a graduate of Shippensburg University, in his spare time he likes to travel, spend time shopping, and spend time with family especially his daughter Addison.